Property Law and Sectional Title

 

 

No, a landlord cannot enter the property whenever they like. Tenants have a right to privacy and the undisturbed use and enjoyment of the property. A landlord may only enter the property with the tenant's knowledge and consent, usually to conduct inspections or carry out necessary repairs. Except in the case of a genuine emergency, the landlord must provide the tenant with reasonable prior notice (often 24 hours or more, as specified in the lease) and arrange a time that is convenient for both parties.

No, a landlord cannot increase the rent arbitrarily. Rent increases must be done in accordance with the terms stipulated in the lease agreement. If the lease is a fixed-term agreement, the rent cannot be increased during that term unless the agreement specifically allows for it under certain conditions (e.g., a rates increase). For month-to-month leases or upon renewal of a fixed-term lease, the landlord must provide the tenant with reasonable written notice of the increase, typically at least one calendar month's notice. The increase should also be reasonable and generally in line with market-related increases. Excessive increases can be challenged at the Rental Housing Tribunal.

Whether a tenant can keep pets or sublet the property depends on the terms of the lease agreement. The lease should clearly state whether pets are allowed and under what conditions. If the lease is silent on pets, the tenant might be allowed to keep them, but it's always best to get the landlord's written consent. Similarly, subletting is usually only permitted if the lease agreement allows it, often with the landlord's prior written consent. Tenants should not assume they can have pets or sublet unless explicitly permitted by the lease or with the landlord's agreement.

A landlord cannot evict a tenant without a court order. The eviction process is governed by the Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act). If a tenant breaches the lease agreement (e.g., by not paying rent) and fails to rectify the breach after receiving written notice, the landlord must follow a legal process to obtain an eviction order from the court. This involves serving notices, applying to the court, and proving the grounds for eviction. The court will consider all relevant circumstances, including the rights of the tenant, particularly in cases involving vulnerable persons. Only the Sheriff of the Court can carry out an eviction order. Illegal evictions, such as changing locks or cutting off utilities, are unlawful.

While a verbal lease agreement is legally binding in South Africa, it is highly recommended to have a written lease agreement. A written agreement provides clarity on the terms and conditions, rights, and obligations of both the landlord and the tenant, which helps prevent disputes. The Rental Housing Act requires a landlord to provide a written lease agreement if the tenant requests it. The Rental Housing Amendment Act, once fully in effect, will require all residential lease agreements to be in writing.

Show all FAQs in Category

Lease Agreements

Navigating Lease Agreements and Early Termination in South Africa

A lease agreement is a cornerstone of the rental relationship in South Africa, establishing the rights and obligations of both landlords and tenants. Whether you are letting out a property or renting one, understanding the legal framework governing these contracts is crucial to protect your interests and avoid potential disputes.

VDM Attorneys specialises in property law and can assist clients with drafting, reviewing, and enforcing lease agreements, as well as resolving disputes, including those arising from early termination.

Lease Agreement Explained

A lease agreement is a legally enforceable contract between a landlord (lessor) and a tenant (lessee) for the temporary letting and hiring of immovable property. It is the foundational document that regulates the terms of the tenancy, including the agreed-upon rental amount, the commencement and duration of the lease period, and the respective rights, duties, and responsibilities of the lessor and lessee regarding the leased premises.

Information contained in a Lease Agreement

Essentially, a lease agreement is a legally binding contract between a lessor (landlord) and a lessee (tenant). It grants the tenant the temporary right to use and occupy a specific property—be it residential or commercial—in exchange for the payment of rent to the landlord. The agreement formalises the terms and conditions of the tenancy, ensuring clarity on aspects such as:

  • Identification of the parties involved
  • Description of the leased property
  • Duration of the lease period
  • Monthly rental amount and payment terms
  • Security deposit requirements and handling
  • Responsibilities for maintenance and repairs
  • Permitted use of the property
  • Conditions for termination and consequences of breach
  • Rules regarding inspections

While verbal lease agreements can be legally binding, they are highly discouraged due to the inherent difficulty in proving terms in the event of a dispute. A comprehensive written lease agreement is always recommended.

The Legal Framework Governing South African Leases

Several key pieces of legislation govern lease agreements in South Africa, providing a framework for fair practices and protecting the rights of both parties:

  • The Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999 This Act is the primary legislation regulating residential leases, outlining the fundamental rights and obligations of landlords and tenants. It promotes fair treatment and sets guidelines for various aspects of the tenancy.
  • The Consumer Protection Act (CPA) 68 of 2008 The CPA provides significant protection to tenants, particularly in instances where the landlord is letting property in the ordinary course of business (e.g., property developers, professional landlords with multiple properties). It ensures that lease agreements are fair, reasonable, and transparent, and importantly, provides tenants (specifically natural persons) with a right to early termination under certain conditions.
  • The Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act) 19 of 1998 This Act governs the process of eviction, ensuring that it is carried out lawfully through a court order, protecting tenants from illegal arbitrary removal.
  • The Property Practitioners Act (PPA) 22 of 2019 The PPA mandates that property practitioners (estate agents) must ensure sellers/landlords complete and sign a comprehensive property defect disclosure form before marketing a property. While primarily aimed at sales, the principle of mandatory disclosure promotes transparency relevant to the condition of a property being leased.

Early Termination of a Fixed-Term Lease

A common point of contention arises when a tenant wishes to terminate a fixed-term lease agreement before its stipulated end date.

Tenant's Right under the CPA

For tenants who are natural persons (not companies or trusts) and where the CPA applies to the lease (i.e., the landlord is letting in the ordinary course of business), Section 14 of the CPA grants the right to cancel the lease before the expiry date. This is done by giving the landlord 20 business days' written notice. This right exists even if the lease agreement does not contain a specific early termination clause.

Landlord's Right to a "Reasonable Penalty"

While the CPA allows for early termination, it also permits the landlord to impose a "reasonable penalty" for such cancellation. The CPA does not specify a fixed amount for this penalty. Instead, its reasonableness is determined by considering factors such as:

  • The remaining period of the lease.
  • The landlord's ability and effort to find a replacement tenant.
  • Any loss of rental income incurred by the landlord until a new tenant is secured.
  • Other reasonable costs directly incurred by the landlord due to the early termination (e.g., advertising costs).
  • It is important to note that a tenant's reason for relocating, such as a job offer elsewhere, while a valid personal circumstance, does not automatically exempt them from this penalty under the CPA or common law, unless the lease agreement specifically makes provision for such circumstances.

Understanding Defects - Patent vs. Latent

Feature Patent Defects Latent Defects
Discoverability Easily identifiable upon reasonable inspection. Not easily discoverable through a reasonable inspection; often hidden.
Visibility Obvious and visible. Hidden or concealed.
Examples Broken windows, visible wall cracks, missing tiles, leaking taps. Concealed damp, rusted internal pipes, faulty geysers, hidden structural issues.
Implication Tenants generally accept the property with visible defects unless otherwise agreed upon in the lease. Landlords generally have a duty to disclose known latent defects that could affect the tenant's use and enjoyment of the property.

Resolving Lease Disputes

Disagreements can arise over various aspects of a lease, including the reasonableness of an early termination penalty, maintenance issues, or deposit returns. Several avenues are available for dispute resolution:

  • Negotiation Open communication between the landlord and tenant is often the first and most effective step. Tenants seeking early termination can attempt to negotiate a reduced penalty or assist the landlord in finding a replacement tenant to mitigate losses.
  • Rental Housing Tribunal Established under the Rental Housing Act, these provincial tribunals offer a cost-effective and accessible platform for mediating and resolving disputes between landlords and tenants. Their decisions are legally binding.
  • Mediation and Arbitration Some lease agreements may include clauses requiring mediation or arbitration before formal legal action. These processes involve a neutral third party assisting in reaching a settlement or making a binding decision.
  • Legal Action If other methods fail, either party may pursue legal action through the courts. This is typically the most time-consuming and expensive option.

Protecting Your Interests - Advice for Landlords and Tenants

To minimise potential disputes and ensure a smooth tenancy:

  • Always use a written lease agreement Ensure it is comprehensive, clearly drafted, and compliant with current South African law.
  • Read the agreement thoroughly Both parties must understand all clauses, including those relating to rent, duration, maintenance, termination, and house rules. Ask questions if anything is unclear.
  • Conduct detailed inspections Perform ingoing and outgoing inspections, ideally with photographic evidence, to document the property's condition at the start and end of the lease.
  • Communicate effectively Maintain clear, preferably written, communication regarding any issues or changes.
  • Know your rights and obligations Familiarise yourself with the relevant provisions of the Rental Housing Act, CPA, and the terms of your specific lease.
  • Honest Disclosure Landlords should disclose any known defects in the property.
  • Seek Legal Advice Before signing a lease, or if a dispute arises, consult with a legal professional specialising in property law.

How VDM Attorneys Can Assist You

Lease agreements can be complex, and navigating the legal landscape requires expertise. VDM Attorneys can provide invaluable assistance to both landlords and tenants by:

  • Drafting and reviewing lease agreements tailored to specific needs and ensuring compliance with all relevant legislation.
  • Advising on your rights and obligations under existing lease agreements and South African law.
  • Assisting with the process of early lease termination, including calculating or challenging reasonable penalties.
  • Representing you in negotiations or dispute resolution processes before the Rental Housing Tribunal or in court.
  • Providing guidance on property defects, disclosure requirements, and potential recourse.

Ensure your lease agreement protects your interests. Contact VDM Attorneys today for expert legal advice and assistance with all your rental property matters.